Making the Case for GEO: How to Win Board Support for the Future of Search

In 2025, the rules of digital visibility are being rewritten — and fast. According to Gartner, 26.6% of scraped keywords now trigger AI overviews on Google’s results pages, pushing traditional organic results further down the screen. Meanwhile, 37% of CMOs are aggressively increasing their SEO/GEO investment, and by 2026, more than one-third of all web content will be created specifically for AI and search engine consumption.

“In 2026, 37% of CMOs are aggressively increasing their SEO/GEO investment.”
Gartner, 2025

    That means the competition for visibility, and credibility, isn’t just about ranking high anymore. It’s about being understood and cited by AI-driven tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google’s Search Generative Experience.

    As an association leader, you already know the landscape of search is changing your association’s visibility and reach. But even when you understand the urgency, your board may not. Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) may sound like “just another marketing line item” or the new “SEO,” which has traditionally received very little investment. 

    So, how do you make the case for GEO in a way that helps the Board understand the potential impact, both positive and negative, and earns their buy-in and funding?

    Associations exist to be the voice of authority in their industries.

    Boards respond when they see a direct connection to the ability to deliver on their vision and mission. GEO isn’t about tinkering with code or keyword stuffing — it’s about ensuring that your members, policymakers, media, and the public can find and trust your expertise in the new era of AI-driven search.

    Board takeaway: If we don’t adapt, our voice risks disappearing from the conversation.

    “If you’re not in the answer, you’re not visible. Challenge your board to ask Gemni or ChatGPT the questions they want to be THE answer for. Get them invested in understanding how answer engines work and both the threat and opportunity they represent.” – Alyssa Hulka

    If AI platforms don’t cite you, your authority erodes.

    Associations produce some of the most authoritative, high-value content online. But if that content isn’t structured for AI to understand and cite, it will be overlooked and replaced by less credible or even incorrect sources. That means lower visibility, weaker influence, and reduced member value.

    Board takeaway: Doing nothing puts us behind organizations that adapt faster.

    Show Them The Numbers

    GEO is tangible and trackable, so start but providing the Board with baseline measurements. Metrics like SEMRush’s SEO and AI visibility scores, prompt topics and citations, GPT inbound traffic from GA4 and more can all demonstrate your current state and show  measurable progress over time. Positioning GEO as a future-proofing investment — with data to back it up — makes it easier for boards to get behind.

    Board takeaway: This isn’t experimental spending. It’s a measurable, strategic investment.

    “GPT sources have actually outpaced organic traffic and sometimes email traffic to sites and sources. It is eye-opening to see GPT outpacing the staple organic sources that we’ve seen hold true over the last 10–15 years.” – Merrik Kressley

    Alyssa Hulka

    Alyssa Hulka

    As the Chief Experience Officer at Accella, Alyssa Hulka is a force in designing transformative digital solutions that elevate associations' impact. Known for her forward-thinking approach, Alyssa crafts digital strategies and high-impact experiences that drive measurable results, including member dashboards that enhance engagement and ROI. Her expertise lies in creating meaningful, technology-driven connections between associations and their members, deploying journey mapping and design thinking to translate member needs into effective digital solutions.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Categories

    Search

    Recent Posts

    Most Common Tags